Home > Technical > Quick fix: Transmission clunk

Quick fix: Transmission clunk

When you find yourself not being able to change gear without a clunk then you may have worn splines on your halfshafts and drive members, due to high mileage or heavy clutch changes. The halfshaft transmits power from the differential by engaging the splines of the drive member which bolts to the hub. Both bits can be changed easily (20 mins) with simple tools and relatively cheaply. Over the years the splines will wear down and a gap will appear, causing the clunk as the wheels catch up to the transmission on gear changes. This makes it a good aspect to check before an expedition and a quick win in preparation where high mileage and high stress driving are likely to occur.

Halfshaft and drive memberWhilst having the clunk won’t stop you being able to drive your Land Rover, the catch up time that the splines have allow them to gain more force and cause a jolt through the whole transmission. This could start wearing your other, more valuable components such as Transfer box and gearbox.

The way to check if this is causing your clunk is to jack up one rear wheel, take the rubber dust cap off and rock the wheel back and forth. If you watch the splines, there should be no play between the halfshaft and the drive member. Mine had old, dirty grease between the splines, which would ooze out as I moved the wheel, so I thought it time for some new halfshafts!

Things you’ll need

For 200Tdi Defender 110:

  • LH rear halfshaft (long) – FRC2455 – £22.49
  • RH rear halfshaft (short) – FRC2454 – £22.49
  • 2 x drive member – FRC5806 – £8.49 each
  • 2 drive member gasket – FRC3988 – £0.28 each
  • 10 x drive member bolts – BX11095M – £0.28 each (optional)

Tools:  External circlip pliers, RTV sealant, Loctite, Grease, a Torque wrench, a 17mm socket, a hammer and an old screwdriver/chisel

What to do

First, drain the axle of oil. Then with the wheel on the ground, break the 5 x 17mm drive member bolts and then jack up and support the wheel. Undo the bolts all the way and hit the drive member with a hammer to rotate it and it will eventually pop away from the hub. If not, use an old screwdriver or chisel to prise it away. Some axle oil will escape.

Inside the hubOld and new drive members and halfshafts

Pull the drive member along with the whole halfshaft out of the axle. You will now see the internals of the hub. Grease the new drive member splines and slide it onto the new halfshaft. Remove the circlip from the outside of the old half shaft and put it on the new one. You can see below the part of the old halfshaft which has worn away from its contact with the drive member.

Old and new halfshaftsWorn halfshaft splines

Remove the traces of gasket from the hub face and put a bead of RTV sealant on it, encircling the bolt holes. Press the gasket onto the sealant and put another bead around the gasket and bolt holes. Slide in the newly assembled halfshaft and drive member. Push down at the drive member end to lever the end of the halfshaft up to engage the differential. It may need a little rotation.

Clean the bolts and put two through the drive member and align it with the holes by turning the wheel and screw in a few turns. Push the drive member flush with the hub – it may require a tap with the hammer. Put Loctite on the 3  bolts and hand tighten them, then do the same for the previous 2 bolts.

Lower the wheel back to the ground and tighten the drive member bolts to 65Nm (48lb/ft) by diagonal selection, as you would with wheel nuts. Add grease around the circlip (you can never have too much grease) and replace the dust cap. There you go! Now do the other one and then fill up the axle with EP90.

This should help reduce the clunking in your gear changes. If it doesn’t then you may have splines worn in other parts of the transfer box, gearbox and differentials, or your lower link bushes are worn.

The finished job

Related posts:

5 Responses to “Quick fix: Transmission clunk”

  1. 29 Mar 10 at 8:31 pm

    I had a similar clunking problem but the splines were OK on the shafts. It turned out that the wear was on the Hub flanges. These were changed for HD ones which come with a nice solid metal cap instead of the rubber ones that regularly get lost in the mud.

    [Reply]

  2. 12 Jul 10 at 5:26 pm

    I’m looking to replace the half shafts on my 300TDi Defender 130 as I know the old ones are worn, my Landy is in Africa at the moment so I’m ordering the kit to take back with me but having not seen it for 6 mths I’m having senior moment. I think I need LH Shaft FTC 1725, RH Shaft FTC 1724 and Drive Flanges RUC105200 can anyone confirm these should be right and is the replacement process on a 300TDI the same as the one above?

    [Reply]

  3. 29 Aug 10 at 7:21 pm

    this is great info. I recently acquired a 1984 Land Rover 110. The left rear hub is leaking but the real concern is the clunk when changing gears. Does the above repair and instruction apply to the old LR 110 as well?

    [Reply]

  4. 6 Mar 11 at 7:25 pm

    Thanks for this great article. I have an old 110 left hand drive I bought ion Switzerland (new) in 1988
    and it is now in South Africa. In 1992 I changed the engine and put myself a second hand 200TDi to replace the Falcon TD engine that everyone (at Land Rover garages in Africa) said it would blow up
    soon or later but rather soon.. Anyway, the 200TDi has now 350’000 km on it and still going strong.
    I am soon going to South Africa for a little private safari with friends (SA & Namibia) and to save time, I have asked a friend there to bring the car to a mechanic for a service and check. And apparently, the rear half shafts need replacement. But the price the guy is quoting me for those parts is enormous. Where do you get those (2455 & 2454) at only 22 pounds ??? These are obviously not genuine parts. Are they good enough ?
    I think I have seen those cheap “copies” somewhere on a website but cannot remember where.
    Should find a shop in South Africa that deal those “cover up” non genuine parts at good price, if anybody knows, thanks a lot.
    Best to all of you
    Olivier Aubert – Zurich Switzerland

    [Reply]

    Land Rover Expedition Reply:

    Hi Olivier

    If you follow the links on the part numbers at the top, it will do a search on some online parts shops for the best price. There are a few that retail around £20. As far as quality goes, they won’t be as good as the genuine items, but I didn’t notice any immediate degradation in performance. The clunk certainly was gone for the next 5000 miles until I sold the vehicle.

    Cheers,
    Will

    [Reply]

Add a comment

Name and Email required. Your email will not be published.